Popular Posts

Wednesday, February 08, 2012

Charles Dickens' A Christmas Carol - A modern day review of the book and of its latest screen adaptation by the Disney in 2009


We small mortals have no authority to measure a giant who spread his wings beyond the century he lived. But I am the new fan of his book after I saw the screen adaptation by Disney. I wish to write a few simple words on the novella to spread the author's social message which is still relevant in our society, as the cause of poverty and its spread are as embarrassing now as it was in the nineteenth century England under Industrial Revolution.  

Charles Dickens was born just two hundred years ago. Here we are reminiscing  one of his master pieces -A Christmas Carol through reviewing its Movie adaptation by Disney carrying the same title.

I am very choosy about movies. The family movies. And as the weather cools down, we pick up worm clothes, Santa begin to knock through Newspaper windows and street shops, Christmas carols and Jesus fills the life space. Other winters we saw Home Alone series to welcome the winter and Christmas, this time also we set ready with it, but The Christmas Carol, the movie blew away all other on Christmas theme. It may sound weir for a devout Hindu to sing in praise of Christmas in a religiously polarized Gujarat, but that’s what our family inherit from the basins of Bengal – Enjoy the spirit of festivity, love the religion, respect others’ food rights and then the religion shrink, humanity blossoms.

Whether you wear a Muslim cap on offer, or a Christian Cross and also carry a Tilok on your forehead – all can coexist on a single body when the soul is incorruptible by greed of power, money, fame and self promotion.

Uncle Scrooge in Disney Movie 2009

Charles Dickens

Now coming back to Dickens on his two hundredth birth centenary – I would pick up The Christmas Carol though David Copperfield and Tale of Two Cities are more popular. For mine, this book and the animation movie released a few years back, taken together, would withstand the taste of time and be one of the best treasures of human creativity ever produced.

The book has taken us back to the 18th century and recreated with artistic sincerity the people and their minds. I love to recollect with a grin the character of uncle Scrooge – the mercenary who would pick up two pence from the dead eye of Morley’s corpse waiting for burial. Being born a poor kid who with sudden change of fortune rose through his profession, had become obsessed with piling up personal wealth while shutting all the relations and other amusements that might attract parting with purse.

He was sorry to part with his childhood sweetheart but couldn’t be too eager when his lover deserted him telling that when they loved each other, they were poor. Now he was rich, but the soul was not the same.

He was so obsessed with himself his own profession, that only thing he knew about was to reach office, do work, and to return home for a cup of soup and sleep. The world outside was closed and he was not interested to know about it. He was a strong disciplinarian with high sense of time management of lone staffer Bob Cratchit  and squeezing as much work as he could from the clerk and would not give any holiday in a year except on Christmas day. But even allowing a day’s leave on full pay to his staff was not to his liking..

 


-         Christmas is the best way to pick the pocket of employer? : Uncle Scrooge tells the staff
-          What Merry Christmas for the poor? Will Christmas bring one penny more in your poor home? : Uncle Scrooge asks his nephew who visit his office to wish him Merry Christmas

Then an earthshaking incident happened on the night of Christmas’ eve as he had opened the door of his lonely big mansion for the night. His long dead business partner Marley's Ghost appeared before him and warned him that a few more Ghosts would come to meet him that night. The uncle Scrooge became scared.

The author’s craft in taking the readers through the uncle Scrooge’s recollection visiting the past, the present and the future with three Ghosts of time separately, gave him the perception of life – he went on a time trail, revisiting those he loved and whether any love left for him and he was shocked to notice that though he had become wealthy over time, a lot of dead skeletons of relations lay behind. He was pained to learn that those acquaintances and relatives had been enjoying taunting  uncle Scrooge behind his back, like a common discussion like this, used to take place :

A Quiz on Tell Me Who is That Fellow? 
A cat ?
No
A dog ?
No
A Horse?
No
Okay , then a horse and an Ass? May I tell you who is he?
Reply came with cheers: Uncle Scrooge 

 .

Uncle Scrooge was deeply pained to see the future time when he was lying dead on the street that many of the elite would not enjoy a visit to his burial place and one amused the others that he could perhaps visit provided a lunch was on offer – a lunch that uncle Scrooge never hosted for anyone in his lifetime..

However in the next destination on the time trail, the uncle Scrooge visited his staff’s home and was greatly surprised by the loyalty and affection of the staff for him as he toasted the night in honour of his misery employer amidst protest by his wife and children. The uncle Scrooge was happy at least one on earth still had love and honour for him.

The over worked lesser paid clerk staff Bob Cratchit is another immortal creation by Dickens - that lovely character remains stamped in viewers memory for ever. A man with high loyalty and love for both - employer and for his family. Perhaps  most of the job seekers on this planet who work either in unorganized or in small medium sector enterprises would feel the same - One a forced life of servitude and the other of dignity, joy and freedom where he can breathe. 

I can’t forget the scene on Christmas Eve as the staff just getting out of the office and handing over the office key to the employer and as the employer turned back and proceeded towards home, Bob's sence of freedom  - like a small boy he ran and trekked in joy on snow carpeted street and fell down, all the while laughing as if he had become younger again like the surrounding celebrating Christmas crowd. Exit from office is an escape to freedom and happiness – an end to begin the new day at night in the company of loved ones. Do some of use feel like that when get battered by the Boss for all the wrong reasons on earth , than efficiency ?

If one see any big city central streets in the evening, you will remember how true the sketch was - all the vehicles and bikes violating rules of the road, breaking speed limit, zooming out in super jet speed only, only to reach home early - as if entering home is the attainment of nirban! That's the psychology of caged birds that human souls are chained in the laboratory of production of goods and services, where labour is viewed just as an element, and that labour which can be replaced by the owner of capital if he finds an iota of doubt that the labour may not be that capital friendly. 


Who can forget that dialogue between the boy on the street and the uncle Scrooge – this dialogues would remain to highlight the spirit of joy on any religious festivity for its followers – the air smells different painted with happiness. 

I would conclude my homage with the author's own dialogue through the lips of uncle Scrooge


What's today, my fine fellow? said Scrooge.
Today! replied the boy. Why, Christmas Day.
It's Christmas DAy! said Scrooge to himself. "I haven't missed it. The Spirits have done it all in one night. They can do anything they like.....Hallo, my fine fellow!"
"Hallo" returned the boy.
"Do you know the poulterer's , in the next street but one, at the corner? Scrooge inquired.
"I should hope I did" replied the lad.
"An intelligent boy!" said Scrooge." A remarkable boy! Do you know whether they've sold the prize turkey that was hanging up there? - Not the little prize turkey, the big one?"
"What, the one as big as me?" returned the boy.
"What a delightful boy!" said Scrooge. "It's a pleasure to talk to him. Yes, my buck!"
"It's hanging there now,", replied the boy.
"Is it?" said Scrooge. " Go and buy it."
"Walk-er!" exclaimed the boy
" No, no," said Scrooge. " I am in earnest. Go and buy it, and tell 'em to bring it here, that I may give them  the directions  where to take it. Come back with the man, and I'll give you a shilling. Come back with him  in less than five minutes, and I'll give you half a crown!"

The boy was off like a shot. He must have had a steady  hand at a trigger who could have got a shot off half so fast.

"I'll send it to Bob Cratchit's," whispered Scrooge, rubbing his hands and splitting with a laugh." He shan't know who sends it. ...."

1 comment:

subhorup dasgupta said...

Very encouraging to have come across your blog and this post. It is heartening to see people still remembering the lost art of Dickens. The modern medium of animation has helped many modern filmgoers relive the work of this literary giant. Thanks for sharing this post.